Date:

Feb 03 2000 10:19:22 EST

From:

Mark Brodsky <Mark@NorthLosGatos.com>

Subject:

Planning; A definition

 

Alastair,
 
I received a wonderful letter from John Miller where he enclosed an
insightful article by his friend Edward McMahon which appeared in the
Planning Commissioners Journal, (#36-Fall 1999).  The article states that
"unfortunately most zoning codes are proscriptive in nature.  They merely
try to prevent bad things from happening without offering a vision of how
things ought to be".
 
This describes a planning department that doesn't have a plan. 
 
 The recent escapades with the North 40 plan show how wrong it is to base
development on a vague general plan.  Even Jan said  "The Council can use
the precedent already set to continue to allow smaller parcels to be
developed in a way that will be coherent and consistent with the Boulevard
Plan."  But  we all now know the Boulevard Plan is fatally flawed by the
gross general plans housing restrictions and 6 lane traffic vision.
 
No wonder our town's planners think a gas station convenience center should
be the official gateway to  Los Gatos Gateway. 
 
The really sad thing is that the Children?s Hospital will happen.  It would
be the perfect start to developing the northern part of the North 60.  It
uses only 10 acres and would aide and benefit from all the North Los Gatos
features like transit, soccer fields,  magnet school, hotel,
conference/theater center and underground parking.    Unfortunately, with
out a detailed plan, our towns planners will let small lots get sold off
piecemeal. Places are being torn down on the neighborhood side of the
boulevard to put an end to any comprehensive vision.    So by the time the
hospital has its funding, the support areas and neighborhood access will be
long gone, turned into a series of low rise offices and convenience stores.
It will probably look a lot like Orange County.
 
If I recall correctly, the last part of the US Constitution says than
anything not written down, (enumerated herein), may still be done by the
people.  The founding fathers had faith in local groups and individuals and
expected laws to "prevent the bad things from happening".  My guess is that
the likes of Madison and Jefferson would hope that town planners would do
more than enforce laws.  I think they would expect town officials to spend
their energies helping and directing those offering visions of how things
ought to be" whether they be home owners building a better nest or
community members calling for building more of the best of the town. 
 
The council wasted $29,000 on planning exercise designed to help rush
through the approval of a gas station. You would think they could spend
about half that much to draw up the concise rendering of what the community
really wants!
 
If not, perhaps the planning department could be renamed to the department
of hoops and hurdles. 
 
Mark
 
 
"If you don't know where you're goin', your gonna wind up where you're
headin'. "   Yogi Berra